top of page

Mentor: Anahita Karthik (she/her)

Category: Young Adult, New Adult, Adult

Sub Genres: Contemporary Romance, Rom Com, Historical Romance, Science Fiction/Fantasy, Dark Romance, Romantic Suspense, Paranormal, Fiction with strong romantic elements, Romantasy, Horroromance, Women’s Fiction, Holiday Romance

  • website
  • instagram
IMG_1987 - Anahita Karthik.jpeg

Bio

Anahita Karthik is a desi, queer, and multilingual writer of stories heavily inspired by Indian mythology, history, and culture. She has an MSt in Creative Writing from University of Cambridge and a tech degree she’ll probably never use in her life. While she writes widely and across genres, her stories usually include road trips, a slow burn romance, and nods to Indian cinema (both explicit and thematic). ‘Better Catch Up, Krishna Kumar’ is her debut novel out with HarperTeen, but her first feature was in ‘My Big, Fat Desi Wedding’ anthology, and she has another forthcoming novel with Avon Books. When not reading or writing, Anahita designs social media graphics, conducts publishing workshops, and mentors querying authors via SmoochPit. She can be found posting excessively across platforms @ana_scribe. She is represented by the stellar Patrice Caldwell at The Caldwell Agency, whom she recently signed with after amicably parting ways with her previous agent and receiving 7 offers of representation from top literary agents.

Manuscript
Wishlist
(MSWL)

I would love to see books that are YA/NA/Adult/crossovers and written by BIPOC writers, especially (but not limited to) queer, disabled, and neurodivergent BIPOC writers. Please note that I am only looking to mentor BIPOC authors at the moment, so if you don't identify as such, please do not submit to me.

 

I read widely, so I’m open to all genres, sub-genres, or genre mashups, but they must have a strong or dominant romantic subplot. I love smut and spice, so don't hesitate to submit novels that have these, and my preference (even in YA novels) tends to be books that rate higher on the chilli peppers scale! I can also take super dark content, so don't hesitate to submit dark novels. My recent favourites and reading patterns can be found on my Goodreads profile, which is linked on my Linktree above.

 

A more specific MSWL:

  • Fluffy, trope-y rom-coms in all the aforementioned age categories that embrace all the cliches. Especially when they're tropes that publishing would like to believe are "overused" but BIPOC authors haven't had a chance to experiment with yet. Tropes I love include: grumpy x sunshine, fake dating, celebrity romance, academic rivals, childhood friends to lovers, enemies/rivals to lovers, exes to lovers, slow burn etc.

  • Romance based around a specific setting—café, spaceship, bakery, tattoo shop, library, small town, spellshop, reality show etc

  • Cozy fantasy romance

  • Historical settings! Bonus points if it’s a non-Western setting.

  • Paranormal romance

  • Urban/Contemporary Fantasy romance

  • Horror Romance. I love f*cked up horroromances and body horror, especially if they're queer.

  • Space Opera/Sci-Fi Romance

  • Thrillers/Murder Mysteries with strong romantic subplots (bonus points if it's a detective/killer romance)

  • Morally gray characters

  • Sapphic stories with lesbian/bi/pan/enby/trans stakes

  • Books inspired by BIPOC myths/mythical creatures/gods/goddesses of the past! Do you have books centering on rakshasas, gumiho, djinns, kappas, and dokkaebi, etc? Send them to me!

  • Dark Academia (bonus points if it’s an all-girls boarding school or has sapphic rep)

  • College romances

  • This might be personal, but please give me more South Asian rep in any/all genres (especially from SA countries historically underrepresented in publishing, like Nepal, Sri Lanka, Maldives, and Bhutan)

  • Fairy tales retold from a BIPOC lens: if it’s a lesser known fairytale, even better

  • Anything that can be comped to a Bollywood movie

  • More Polyamorous/Open relationship stories

 

Here's what I don't want to see/what I wouldn't be a good champion for:

  • Younger or lower YA

  • Novels that aren’t by BIPOC authors

  • Novels longer than 100k words

  • Novels that don’t have a primary/strong romantic plot/sub-plot

  • Novels that aren't polished/well-formatted

Mentoring Style

When I've picked my mentee, I first send over a detailed edit letter and a copy of their full manuscript with my initial thoughts/comments. Then I hop on a call to address any queries they might have before they begin developmental edits. Of course, none of my revisions/suggestions are compulsory, because no one knows your story better than you, and you’re free to take or pass on whatever notes you like! After those are done, I might send over more revisions, or move on to line edits with more comprehensive thoughts in the comments of the revised manuscript. While the mentee tackles further revisions/edits, I would ask them to send over their pitch + query letter + synopsis, and help tighten their submission package. 

 

Even after the mentorship and showcase, I'd love to discuss querying strategies and potential offers. As for during the course of the mentorship, I will be available to communicate and chat via Email/WhatsApp/Zoom/Google Meet. I am a friend first and a mentor second, and I hope to be there for the mentee even after the mentorship is over. I hope to be the person that the mentee can excitedly text no matter where they are in their writing journey, someone they can confide in about moving on and growing with each rejection they might receive, and someone who not just encourages them to power on, but also reminds them to take breaks.

 

My first SmoochPit mentee, Cynthia Timoti, went on to receive two offers of representation from agents after the mentorship was over, and eventually clinched a two-book deal with Bramble, a romance imprint at Macmillan. The same book, 'Salty, Spiced, and a Little Bit Nice,' is out now. My second mentee, Yi-Jun O, whom I mentored two years back for their alternate historical science-fantasy, 'Fractured Beginnings, Fracturing Ends,' received an offer of representation within ten days of the SmoochPit showcase. My third mentee, Susan Hong, is querying at the moment, and prior to jumping into the trenches, I set up a call with one of her favourite authors, the one who'd written a book she'd comped her project to, helping her gain fuller perspective about the genre she is querying. I love making my mentees feel special, and tailored my mentorship style to suit each of their needs. I'm still in touch with all of them: I blurbed Cynthia's sophomore novel, yapped about Yi-Jun's second project with them, and met Susan in person during my first-ever trip to NYC! I have nothing but endless respect and love for them, because these are some of the most important relationships in my life!

 

I know exactly what it takes to make an agent hit the full request button, because I've gone from receiving 300+ query rejections to garnering 30+ full/partial requests for the novel that got me my first agent back in 2022, and then recently receiving 7 offers of representation when I re-queried this year from top literary agents, eventually leading me to sign with Patrice Caldwell at The Caldwell Agency. I have conducted multiple successful publishing workshops, and done hundreds of query and submission package critiques. More than even my knowledge of this industry, I love being a mentor, and will bring endless enthusiasm, passion, and support to the table if I do end up picking you, and we find ourselves the perfect fit!

Applications
from Connections

Please do not apply to me if we've ever beta read for each other or have had extensive conversations online. If we're in the same discord(s) or mutuals on social media but haven't talked more than a comment on a post here or there, feel free to apply. If you've ever DMed me with a publishing query, that's okay, you can submit to me.

bottom of page